about us

view our coins

investments

services

contact

company news

home

 

Rare coin investing


The ‘rare coins’ market represents a compelling from of alternative investment. Providing sufficient due diligence is undertaken forming a portfolio, coin investment can offer both the opportunity for attractive returns and low correlations with other assets. The market is, by its nature, supply constrained. As such, growing interest in the market should support rising prices over the medium to long term.

The most liquid markets for rare coins are generally within their country of origin. ‘Ancient coins’ are generally defined as those that were produces prior to c 500 AD and date back as far as 600 BC, when the earliest known coinage was introduced. As such, quality is a key determinant of value. Prices are determined at auction and liquidity is provided by a base of world wide collectors.

Diversification
As a developing class of alternative investments, rare coins benefit from low correlation with other investments and in some cases offer more liquidity than other like real estate and venture capital.

Inflation hedge
Unlike fixed income investments such as bonds, prices of ancient coins should rise in line with general economic growth and inflation.

Good potential long-term returns
Although the spectrum of potential returns varies widely across different individual coins and collections, recent auctions have highlighted that attractive returns can be achieved. Long term collections (50 years plus) have achieved compound annual returns of between 8.7%-10.5%. The FTSE All-Share has delivered a compound annual return of 7.8% over the last 42 year period.

Short term returns also attractive
Although past performance is no indication of future growth, a random portfolio of gold and silver coins, selected from the Spinks auction catalogue over the last 6 years, would have generated a compound annual return of 12.0%.

A growing market
For the above reasons, interest in the rare coins market has increased over recent years; rare coins represent a relatively large and increasingly liquid alternative investment market, offering investors the ability to diversify their portfolios in order to achieve potentially higher returns and lower overall portfolio volatility.

A good time to diversify?
The US coin market has recovered steadily from a bubble that burst during the early 1990s, but prices remain significantly below that of the peaks reached towards the end of the 1980s. The recovery has coincided with a lacklustre performance from equity markets - the S&P 500 remains 32% below its March 2000 high. Although the global economy has begun to recover, the outlook remains unclear given concerns over high consumer debt and rising oil prices.

coins

1998

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

Total Gain

CAGR

GOLD

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

GEORGE III GUINEA 1813

800

800

800

900

1000

1250

1750

1950

144%

0.0%

ANNE. 5 GUINEA 1705

5500

6500

6500

6500

6500

6500

8000

12000

118%

11.8%

GEORGE II EIC 5 GUINEA 1729

4000

4500

4500

5000

5250

6500

7500

9000

125%

12.3%

GEORGE I GUINEA 1714

2200

2300

2500

2500

2750

3500

4500

5000

127%

12.4%

HENRY VIII ANGEL

725

825

900

950

1200

1250

1450

1750

141%

13.4%

GEORGE IV SOVEREIGN

575

575

575

575

575

700

1250

1500

161%

14.7%

MARY SOVEREIGN

3750

4500

4500

4750

5500

6500

7250

7250

93%

9.9%

ELIZABETH I SOVEREIGN

3100

5250

5250

5500

6250

7000

7000

8500

174%

15.5%

CROMWELL BROAD

5500

6000

6000

6000

6500

8000

12500

12500

127%

12.4%

GEORGE VI SOVEREIGN 1937

375

400

425

400

400

600

750

950

153%

14.2%

EDWARD III NOBLE

700

750

800

850

1000

1400

1500

1650

136%

13.0%

SILVER

 

GEORGE I SSC SHILLING 1723

85

85

85

100

150

175

250

300

253%

19.7%

VICTORIA GOTHIC CROWN 1847

1250

1250

1250

1450

1750

2000

2250

2500

100%

10.4%

VICTORIA HALF CROWN 1842

375

450

450

450

500

600

750

850

127%

12.4%

GEORGE III CROWN 1818

325

350

350

350

350

450

550

750

131%

12.7%

GEORGE III HALF CROWN 1819

200

200

200

200

250

300

350

400

100%

10.4%

GEORGE IV CROWN 1821

850

850

850

850

1000

1200

200

2250

165%

14.9%

NEWARK SHILLING

475

575

625

675

750

850

1000

1200

153%

14.2%

PHILIP & MARY SHILLING

500

550

550

600

675

800

975

1100

120%

11.9%

COMMONWEALTH CROWN

650

675

675

750

850

1000

1350

1450

123%

12.1%

TOTAL VALUE

31,935

37,385

37,785

39,350

43,200

50,575

62,925

72850

128%

12.5%

                           
     

COMPOUND ANNUAL GROWTH RATE (CAGR)

  17.1% 8.8% 7.2% 7.8% 9.6% 12.0% 12.5%    
     

PORTFOLIO CHANGE ON PREVIOUS YEAR

  17.1% 1.1% 4.1% 9.8% 17.1% 24.4% 15.8%    
 
 

 

SOURCE PRICES FROM SPINK COINS OF ENGLAND CACR - COMPOUND ANNUAL GROWTH RATE

Case study - a sample coin portfolio

The above portfolio of coins was selected at random from the Spink Coins of England catalogue over the last 8 years. Although individual coin prices can remain static over the short-term, medium term returns have been attractive.

[info@nobleinvestmentsplc.com] © noble investments (uk) plc